Was Prot really an alien? Ask Question Asked 8 years, 3 months ago. Active 4 years ago. Viewed 49k times 16. 2. After reading the first K-PAX book for the second time, I became convinced that. Prot was not an alien. However, after reading the second and third books, I changed my mind and thought that. Prot was an alien.
Like the universe, the movie K-PAX presents the viewer with a dilemma about the identity of Robert Porter without explicitly stating the identity of Porter. Due to the information presented in the movie, “Prot,” is a fictitious persona of Robert Porter. This is the claim will be argued throughout the essay.